Every broker review says “client funds are segregated” and stops there. That sentence is doing an enormous amount of work, and most traders have no idea what it actually promises — or what it does not.
The question is not academic. Retail CFD brokers fail. They fail from a market event that outruns their risk controls, from a funding squeeze, from fraud, or simply from running out of cash while holding other people’s money. The 2015 Swiss franc shock took out one of the largest FCA-regulated brokers in the market in four days. The mechanism by which you get your money back — or do not — is fully documented, publicly tested, and almost never read.
This guide walks through it: what segregation really means, which compensation scheme applies to which entity, why the number you have read is probably attached to a different licence than the one you hold, and what a real recovery looks like in months rather than theory.
Research note: scheme limits verified against FSCS, CySEC, AFCA and ASIC publications in November 2026. Alpari UK case figures drawn from published administrator and FSCS reporting.
The four layers between you and a total loss
Think of broker failure protection as four layers, in order of how much work they do.
Layer 1 — Segregation. Your deposit sits in a designated client-money bank account, legally separate from the firm’s own operating funds. If the firm fails, that money is not available to its creditors. This is the layer that returns most of the money in most failures, and it is the only layer that works instantly and without a claim.
Layer 2 — Negative balance protection. If a gap move takes your account below zero, the broker writes the deficit off rather than billing you for it. This is mandatory for EU and UK retail clients and offered voluntarily by many offshore entities. It protects you from owing money, not from losing it.
Layer 3 — Compensation scheme. If segregation leaves a shortfall, a statutory or industry fund pays eligible clients up to a limit. This is the layer with the numbers attached — £85,000, €20,000 — and the layer that takes years.
Layer 4 — Dispute resolution. If the broker is still solvent but will not pay you, an ombudsman or complaints authority can order it to. AFCA in Australia, the Financial Ombudsman Service in the UK, CySEC’s complaint process in Cyprus. This layer works on conduct disputes, not insolvency.
The critical thing to understand is that layers 1 and 2 attach to the entity, layer 3 attaches to the regulator of that entity, and layer 4 attaches to membership of a scheme in that jurisdiction. Nothing attaches to the brand.
Segregation: what it does and does not do
Properly executed segregation means client money is held in a trust or designated account, reconciled daily, and never used to fund the firm’s own positions. In the EU and UK it is a regulatory requirement with specific rules attached; in most offshore jurisdictions it is a licence condition but enforced far more loosely.
Here is what segregation does not do.
- It does not protect against a shortfall created by the firm’s own losses. If the broker’s hedging operation lost more than its own capital and the money came out of a pooled account it should not have touched, there is less in the pool than clients are owed. This is exactly what the compensation scheme is for.
- It does not protect against the administrator’s costs. In the UK’s special administration regime, the costs of the administration are met from the client-money pool before distribution. That is one reason recovery is rarely 100 cents on the dollar even when the money was properly held.
- It does not protect an open position. A CFD is a contract with the broker, not an asset held in custody. At insolvency, open positions are closed and your claim becomes the resulting cash balance. If the close happens at a bad price because the market is in the middle of the event that killed the broker, that price is your claim.
- It does not apply to money you never deposited. Sounds obvious. In practice, traders who funded a “managed account” or sent money to an individual “account manager” have no client-money claim at all, because the money never entered a client account.
The practical test: does the client agreement name a designated client-money account, and does your deposit confirmation show that account name? If it does not, the segregation promise is marketing.
Compensation schemes, entity by entity
This is the table that matters, and the reason the entity name on your agreement is more important than the regulator logos on the homepage.
| Regulator of your onboarding entity | Scheme | Limit | Covers trading losses? |
|---|---|---|---|
| FCA (UK) | FSCS | £85,000 per person, per firm | No — only firm failure |
| CySEC (Cyprus) | Investor Compensation Fund (ICF) | Lower of 90% of claim and €20,000 | No |
| ASIC (Australia) | None for client money | — | — |
| FSCA (South Africa) | No general scheme | — | — |
| DFSA (DIFC) | No general retail scheme | — | — |
| FSC Belize / FSA Seychelles / FSC BVI | None | — | — |
Three of those rows need unpacking, because the popular summaries get them wrong.
The UK: £85,000, not £120,000. The FSCS investment limit for a firm that failed after 1 April 2019 is £85,000 per eligible person per firm. The £120,000 figure that has been circulating since late 2025 is the deposit limit for savings in a UK-authorised bank, building society or credit union, raised on 1 December 2025. It did not touch the investment limit, and a leveraged CFD balance is investment business, not a deposit. It is also per firm, not per account — two accounts under the same legal entity share one £85,000 ceiling, and two brands sharing one FCA authorisation share it too.
Cyprus: €20,000 is a ceiling on 90%. The ICF pays the lower of 90% of the covered claim and €20,000. A client owed €15,000 receives €13,500, not €15,000. A client owed €100,000 receives €20,000. That 90% structure is frequently omitted from comparison tables that quote “€20,000 cover”.
Australia: there is no fund. This is the most misunderstood row. An ASIC licence is genuinely valuable — capital requirements, conduct rules, client-money rules, a real dispute-resolution body in AFCA — but Australia has no compensation scheme for CFD client money. AFCA can consider claims up to A$1,263,000 and award up to A$631,500 for direct financial loss from 1 January 2024, and that is a powerful remedy against a solvent broker that has mistreated you. It is not a fund that pays when a broker fails. The Compensation Scheme of Last Resort, operating since 2 April 2024, pays up to A$150,000 per claim — but only for unpaid AFCA determinations in personal financial advice, credit provision, credit intermediation and securities dealing. A retail CFD complaint generally falls outside it. Any broker advertising “ASIC regulated, so your funds are protected up to A$X” is overstating what the licence does.
The honest summary: after segregation and negative balance protection, tier-1 regulation gives you better conduct rules, better capital standards, a real complaints path and a stronger chance that segregation was actually done properly. It does not always give you a cheque.
The Alpari UK case: what recovery actually looks like
The template failure is Alpari (UK) Limited, and it is worth knowing in detail because it is the only recent large-scale worked example in a tier-1 jurisdiction.
On 15 January 2015 the Swiss National Bank removed the EUR/CHF floor. The pair gapped roughly 30% in seconds. Client accounts across the industry went deeply negative, and brokers holding those positions absorbed losses they were never capitalised for. Alpari UK entered special administration on 19 January 2015 — four days later — with KPMG partners appointed as joint special administrators.
What followed is the realistic sequence:
- Trading stopped. Positions were closed. The claim became the resulting cash balance, not the position.
- Client money in segregated accounts was pooled and returned in proportion to claims, after the administrators’ costs were met from it.
- The FSCS paid eligible clients up to the limit prevailing at the time — £50,000 per person, not today’s £85,000.
- By mid-2016 the FSCS had paid roughly $51.3 million to 11,751 clients.
- Clients with balances above the compensation limit recovered an estimated 78–80 cents on the dollar.
- Clients who had gone into negative balance owed money back rather than being owed it, and administrators pursued those debts separately from the compensation process.
- The High Court ordered the administration closed on 19 April 2018, more than three years after it began.
Two lessons. First, the system worked: money was returned, a scheme paid out, and nobody was left with nothing simply because the broker failed. Second, “worked” meant three years of frozen funds, claim portals, progress reports and partial recovery above the cap. If you are running a five-figure balance at any broker, that outcome is a real risk to plan around — and the plan is not a compensation claim, it is not keeping a five-figure balance at one broker.
The questions that actually predict your outcome
Forget the licence list. These five questions separate a broker whose failure you would survive from one where you would be a claimant.
1. Which legal entity is named on my client agreement? Not the brand. The legal entity. Then check that name on the regulator’s public register. In 2026 it is routine for a group to market one brand while operating six entities, and the one that holds your money is the one in the contract.
2. Are client funds designated as client money, and at which banks? A proper disclosure names the banks. Vague language about “segregated accounts at top-tier banks” without naming them is a yellow flag, not a red one, but it is worth asking support in writing.
3. Is there a compensation scheme attached to that entity, and what is the exact limit? Use the table above, then verify it on the scheme’s own website. If the answer is “the group is regulated by the FCA”, ask which entity, and whether your account is with it.
4. What is the negative balance protection policy, and is it contractual? For EU and UK retail clients this is mandatory. For an offshore entity it is voluntary, and the wording of the client agreement is what counts, not the FAQ page.
5. How much of my capital is at one counterparty? This is the question nobody asks and the one that determines your real exposure. A compensation cap of £85,000 does not help a $12,000 account, and it does not help much above it either if recovery takes three years. Splitting balances across two regulated entities is the only protection that works without a claim.
How this looks for an Asian retail trader in 2026
The uncomfortable arithmetic: most traders in Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines are onboarded to a Belize, Seychelles, Mauritius or BVI entity, where the compensation scheme is None and the enforcement budget is small. The protection that remains is segregation, negative balance protection, the broker’s own capital, and your choice of how much to leave on deposit.
That is not a reason to avoid those brokers — it is a reason to size your exposure to them deliberately. A trader running $300 on a $10 minimum-deposit account has almost nothing at risk from broker failure relative to trade risk. A trader running $40,000 at the same broker has a counterparty problem, not a trading problem.
Where an ASIC licence does change the calculus is that it moves the entity itself into a tier-1 regime with real capital and conduct rules — which is the reason UZFX’s ASIC licence (AFSL 001291473) matters more than any scheme limit, since Australia has no fund to fall back on. Verify it yourself in the ASIC professional registers rather than trusting any review, including this one.
Our negative balance protection guide covers layer 2 in detail, and the broker vetting checklist turns these five questions into a scoring routine you can run before funding.
FAQ
Do I get my money back if my forex broker goes bust? Usually most of it, eventually. Segregated funds are returned first, then a compensation scheme covers eligible clients up to its limit. Alpari UK clients saw segregation largely hold, FSCS payouts to 11,751 clients, and recovery of roughly 78-80 cents for balances above the cap — over three years.
Which compensation scheme protects my CFD account? Whichever scheme belongs to the entity on your client agreement. FCA entity: FSCS £85,000. CySEC entity: ICF at the lower of 90% and €20,000. ASIC entity: no fund for client money. Belize/Seychelles/BVI entity: no fund.
Is £85,000 or £120,000 the FSCS limit? £85,000 is the investment limit and applies to broker client money. £120,000 is the bank deposit limit raised in December 2025 and does not apply to a trading account.
Does segregated client money guarantee a full refund? No. It ring-fences funds from the firm’s creditors but does not cover shortfalls from the firm’s own losses, administrator costs, or operational error — which is why compensation schemes exist on top of it.
How do I check where my money actually sits? Read the client agreement for the exact legal entity, look it up on the regulator’s register, check the client-money disclosure for named banks, and confirm the deposit confirmation matches the regulated entity name.
Final Verdict
Broker failure is survivable but slow, and the difference between “annoying” and “catastrophic” is decided before you deposit, by which entity you sign with and how much you leave there. Segregation is the protection that does most of the work. Compensation schemes are the backstop, and they are smaller, slower and more conditional than the marketing suggests — £85,000 with no 90% haircut in the UK, €20,000 with a 10% haircut in Cyprus, and nothing at all in Australia despite the strength of the licence itself.
The practical conclusion is unglamorous. Read the entity name. Verify it on the register. Ask where the client money sits. Do not run a balance at one broker that you could not afford to have frozen for three years. And treat “regulated” as a statement about conduct and capital, not as an insurance policy, because that is exactly what it is.
Risk Disclaimer: Trading forex and CFDs involves significant risk of loss and is not suitable for all investors. Leverage magnifies both gains and losses. Compensation scheme limits, client-money rules and insolvency procedures described here reflect published regulator and scheme documentation as of November 2026 and change over time — verify current terms with the scheme and the regulator before relying on them. This article is educational and does not constitute legal or financial advice; recovery outcomes in any future insolvency will differ from historical cases.
Last reviewed: 16 November 2026. Research and editorial by the MarketCFD broker review team. Related reading: negative balance protection guide, broker vetting checklist, UZFX review 2026.